Thursday, April 7, 2011

Analyzing Scope Creep

The week six assignment is to post a blog using the following as a guide. Describe a project, either personal or professional, that experienced issues related to scope creep. What specific scope creep issues occurred? How did you or other stakeholders deal with those issues at the time? Looking back on the experience now, had you been in the position of managing the project, what could you have done to better manage these issues and control the scope of the project?


This project was about skirmishing illiteracy among adults in Ghana. According to the URL below, the project started as mass literacy campaign in 1951 as part of overall community development program. The primary aim of this project was to teach adult to read and write in their own languages as well as in English language. Efforts continued during the 1950s and the 1960s, and in the 1970s an extensive literacy campaign was launched under the direction of the Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare using mass education teams. Literacy classes for adults were also conducted by local units of the Peoples' Education Association, a voluntary organization founded in 1949. This group, which included teachers, graduates, students, and interested persons, had branches throughout the country (Ministry, L. S., 1994).


Despite such organizational efforts, it was estimated by the United Nations in 1970 that about 70 percent of the nation's inhabitants above the age of fifteen (57 percent of males and 82 percent of females) were illiterate. The 1970 figure was a 5 percent improvement over an estimated 1960 adult literacy rate of 25 percent. During the 1989 New Year School held at the University of Ghana, for example, the relationship between adult education and economic development was emphasized in a speech read by the then president, Flight Lieutenant Jerry John Rawlings. Also in 1989, reliable press reports held that the adult literacy rate in Ghana was about 40 percent of the total population; of the 60 percent of the population that was illiterate, 57 percent was female. Even though the 1989 figure was an improvement over that of 1970, the National Council on Women and Development still expressed concern and described the low percentage of literate adult females as alarming. The council attributed female illiteracy to high dropout rates in the elementary schools and called on the government to find ways to enforce compulsory education in the country (Ministry, L. S. ,1994).


In 1992, the project finally reached the village where I was teaching. I immediately became part of the grogram assisting in educating the adult learners because I am always passionate of making an impact in any society where I found myself. I believe in a title of a song I learned in my childhood “Brighten the Corner Where You Are”. The majority of the people in the project were women ages 15 – 55. The specific scope creep issue that occurred was that the government did not allocate enough funds for this project. This was a year long project however, when the project was half way through, there was an increased in participants with limited funds. The project could not continue nor were the people on the wait list able to get in the program. The stakeholders were upset threatening to demonstrate their right in equal education law.


During this time, the manager met with all stakeholders to explain the issue. It was not easy at all. There was anxiety amongst the stakeholders. We then decided to do some voluntary work to improve the scope creep. I volunteered more hours in addition to weekends. Other stakeholders did the same to deal with one part of the issue, to accommodate as many learners as possible. In order to deal with the second part of the issue to get more funds for purchasing materials for the project, most stakeholders decided to organize a communion labor to generate some funds to continue the project since the government could not afford it as planned. We were able to help farmers plowed, sowed, harvested crops during each season of the project. It was a challenge because the instructional time was decreased for community labor.


Portny (2008) asserted that avoiding scope creep is not possible. However, monitoring it, controlling it, and thereby reducing some of the pain is possible if the project manager follows a few guidelines (pg. 347). As I look back on the experience now, had I been in the position of managing the project, what I could have done to better manage these issue in order to control the scope of the project were to utilize Portny’s advice as follows:

Include a change control system in every project planned.

Insists that every project change is introduced by a change order that includes a description of agreed-upon change together with any resulting changes in the plan, processes, budget, schedule, or deliverables.

Require changes by approved in writing by the client as well as the representatives of senior management.

Amend and updates all project plans and schedules to reflect the change after the change order has been approved.


References

Portny, S. E., Mantel, S. J., Meredith, J. R., Shafer, S. M., Sutton, M. M., &

Kramer, B. E. (2008). Project management: Planning, scheduling, and

controlling projects. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc

Ministry, L. S. (1994). Ghana-A Country Study. Accra: Government of Ghana.

Retrived on April 7, 2011

from http://www.country-data.com/cgi-bin/query/r-5253.html

5 comments:

  1. Hi Stella,
    I commend your efforts to improve the literacy rates in Ghana. This is an amazing story.

    It sounds like the project might have been ill-planned and ill-funded from the beginning. A year-long project to improve literacy sounds like a drop in the bucket with the number of illiterate adults in the area. Then again, a major social change like this has to start somewhere. Good for you and your colleagues in not giving up when the going got tough.

    Cheers,
    Joe

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Stella.

    I really enjoyed reading your post about your work in Ghana. It is a truly amazing story to hear of everyone coming together to make sure the money was raised and as many people as possible were helped. It sounds like no matter what you did, you could not prevent scope creep since you were not given the funding you were told you would. Even if you had underestimated and then overdelivered as our Media tells us you would still struggled with your budget. It is great to here that everyone put in extra hours and raised the money themselves. A truly inspiring story! Thank you for sharing it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Da Stella!

    I would like to challenge Portny et al. (2008) asserting that avoiding scope creep is not possible. I would like to submit that a PM could avoid a scope creep by defining a proactive system of risk management to offset the birth of scope creep. It is not easy to read minds but as SME, a PM could use work breakdown structure (WBS) (Geer, 20110, develop, and could monitor a mechanism to enable team members to objectively identify and manage project risks. Portny et al. (2008) remarked: "However, monitoring it, controlling it, and thereby reducing some of the pain is possible if the project manager follows a few guidelines (pg. 347". Consistent risk management and monitoring should surface in all stages of a design project to avoid a poor design project outcome (Yee, Lievesley, and Taylor, 2009). This risk management should eventually extend to the life of the project.

    Scope creep is a fundamental issue in a project management. Any PM could easily avoid scope creep through a clear and effective communication between all participants. The PM has the responsibility to have a sign off document listing agreed upon details for measures to avoid scope creep and have successful project outcomes.

    References

    Geer, M. (2011). The project management minimalist: Just enough PM to rock your projects! Retrieved from http://sylvan.live.ecollege.com/ec/courses/56611/CRS-CW-4894953/educ_6145_readings/pm-minimalist-ver-3-laureate.pdf.

    Portny, S.E., Mantel, S.J. Meredith, J.R., Shafer, S.M., & Sutton, M.M. (2008). Project management: Planning, scheduling, and controlling projects. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

    Yee, J., Lievesley, M., & Taylor, L. (2009). Recognizing risk-of-failure in communication design projects. Visible Language, (43)2, 227-251.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Stella,
    This is Bessie, just wanted to inform that for this course I will be following your blog. I am look forward to learn with and from you.

    Bessie Walker

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi

    Its great to be working with you again. I am looking forward to following your blog.

    Dreana

    ReplyDelete